Confirmation of Petition

[squeaky-spooky.livejournal.com]

Apparently the rumors about a petition in Korea to cancel the Hetalia anime are true:

http://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2009-01-13/korean-protests-call-for-hetalia-anime-cancellation

No plans to cancel it as of yet. Interestingly enough, there were never plans for Korea to be in the anime.

Comments

[kenichi-bokushi.livejournal.com]

Exactly! First of all, anyone who actually takes the time to do the research would notice that the guy who writes it is Japanese, but has been living in America for quite a long time, and he has even drawn these things while there. He even often uses the pages for the strips, as well as his blog, to show off some of the sights of America to the people who read it. Somehow, that doesn't seem like the type of person who would make up something that would label America as "the bad guys." Few people would be idiotic enough to make something that depicts America as the bad guys of World War II while within America's borders, and somehow, he doesn't strike me as an idiot by any stretch of the imagination. Also, they don't consider that he didn't even spare Japan from having its own foibles, such as being a sort of dull, extremely submissive character who has an obsession with cute things.

Second of all, the thing with World War II being a setting for comedy is nothing new. Any of them heard of the musical South Pacific? That's a comedy specifically dealing with the military that takes place in World War II, and there are plenty of stereotypes in it, but I was in a pretty well-publicised production of it in 1999, and there was no protest to be found anywhere. Any of them heard of a certain comedy/drama set in the Korean war that goes by the name of ... oh, I don't know, M*A*S*H? Using the war as a setting is nothing new and is not automatically bad.

Not to mention that only some of the strips even have to do with the war. The bulk of the strips on Himaruya's site have nothing at all to do with WWII -- many of them, in fact, are from the modern era (e.g. China's copyright infringement amusement park, Sealand's struggle to be recognised, the Baltic trio's post-Russian control struggles, etc.) The setting ranges from all the way back in ancient times to the present.

However, none of that matters to those who protest it, because all they look at is just what's on the surface, just like an actual racist does when he/she sees someone who looks different from him/her.

[kiwifruiti.livejournal.com]

True, true. I actually didn't even know that Hidekaz lived in New York till someone brought it up casually a few days ago. I think that's pretty cool. (I wonder if that's why he was able to portray the relationship between America and Canada so well. XD)

As for the second point, that's pretty much the reason why I won't be too concerned if Hetalia is licensed in North America. It seems quite a few people are worried about the possible backlash, but like you pointed out above WWII comedies (or comedies set during other wars for that matter) are nothing new. Plus if we're talking stereotypes and laughing at other countries, Hetalia is nowhere near as controversial as popular American shows like Family Guy or South Park.

Also like you said many of the strips don't have anything to do with WWII at all. The whole comic is parody of international relations in general (past and present), if anything.